April 04, 2005

Welcome to planet Zog

A most valued reader forwards the following link to me:

It might be big, but it will never be dumb

There is a myth in telecommunications companies today – partly promoted by the newly integrated IT guys – that the most economical way forward for networks is for the whole network to evolve into a “big dumb network”. […]

Well, just as there never is a free lunch, there will never be a big dumb network – at least not unless there are big dumb operators.

You don’t say! It only gets better…

A critical step for the immediate introduction of NGN services will be an open discussion on how much intelligence will actually be in the network – a big clever network – and where it should be located. Then, how this intelligence can be used to seamlessly support issues like NGN roaming, consistent inter-domain SIP handling and (inter-domain) QoS must be considered. These are time critical issues, as purchasing decisions for NGN equipment are now under way.

Ah! NGN roaming, what a beautiful concept. I’m sure I’ll create a great deal of end-user value. I guess all those Skype calls I’ve made around the world on weedy DSL and WiFi links — while running a BitTorrent client in the background and no QoS — were just an illusion.

Ever get the feeling these guys are having an oh shit moment, and realising that their smart network business just reached its use-by date?

PS — I’ll write about Freedom to Connect real soon, but I’ve had a bad head cold and awful jetlag for a few days, and real-world business needs to be sorted out first.

Posted by Martin Geddes at 02:00 PM
Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.telepocalypse.net/cgi-sys/cgiwrap/mgeddes/MT/mt-tb.cgi/443.

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Welcome to planet Zog:

» Skype and other VoIP services as well as other IP apps run just fine without QOS from North American Bandwidth News
[Read more]

Tracked on April 5, 2005 07:58 AM
Comments

I have recently come across a good piece called Insects and Entropy. (Actually, I think entropy is the wrong word, but never mind.) This is an Aesop fable for our time, involving a complex hare and a simple tortoise - or is it the other way around? Complex and powerful behaviours can be produced by composing simple behaviours. I think this helps to resolve the debate about big clever networks. See my blog at http://www.veryard.com/so/2005/04/emergent-intelligence.htm

Posted by: at April 7, 2005 05:29 AM
Please enter your comment below. Your comment will not appear immediately -- they all go for pre-approval by me because of the volume of spam I receive.







Remember personal info?